|
The Thriving National Ecological Balance: A Comparative Analysis of Wild Free-Roaming Horses & Burros In Relation to Habitat,
Wildlife and Livestock Populations” by C.R. MacDonald, October, 2009
Recently, Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar Sez’s, “ There’s just no room
for wild horses and burros out West anymore”. With the drought taking its toll on Western rangelands, wildlife
struggling to survive, and out of control reproduction rates and populations of wild horses and burros constantly threatening
fragile arid habitats, Salazar Sez’s, " The time has come to sterilize most of what is left, both on and off the
range, and ship America’s Mustangs & Burros to private sanctuaries far removed from their native ranges on public
lands". Salazar Sez’s, “ Let us not look behind the scenes at how we got here but only look ahead
at this new solution for the Wild Horse & Burro Program”, a solution many are already coining the final
one. Never mind the fact that for two decades, the Government Accountability Office has repeatedly issued
reports stating the obvious; BLM cannot provide evidence that removing wild horses and burros improves rangeland health and
that the entire concept of excess is based on “informal decisions made by BLM Field Managers” – no data
required. Salazar Sez’s, “ Who needs BLM to finally publish their long-awaited acreage report before
they hustle more wild horses and burros off the range to multi-million dollar private sanctuaries instead?” And,
“ Why bother publishing the new policy manual BLM has been writing (for 40 years now!) to establish guidelines on
how BLM should go about determining what is appropriate use for wild horses and burros?” After all, BLM would just
ignore it anyway like so much else - so why create a legal precedent before shipping most of them
to privately owned sanctuaries? Salazar Sez’s, “ Who needs a Congressional investigation into what the
Department of the Interior has done to get us to this point?” Despite the DOI’s abysmal reputation for ethic
violations, never mind that now, Salazar’s here and those days are behind us! Salazar Sez’s, “ We
don’t need an independent count of what’s in the holding pens” – despite the fact that nobody
has ever seen all these “excess” horses causing such financial distress. And Salazar doesn’t seem too interested
in looking into an independent census of what’s still remaining on the range because, as Salazar Sez’s, “ We
are going to create a new home for them now anyway!”Despite nearly a decade of mass cleansings, which has
swept the majority of our herds from their ranges, Salazar Sez’s, “ Danger! Danger! Excessive wild horses and
burros must go now!” and as a result, BLM has scheduled the removals of over 12,000 more wild horses and burros
this year based solely on those ‘informal manager decisions’ – even though Salazar’s own home state
of Colorado has reported their 292,000 elk have been “over population objectives for the last 20 years” (1) – what’s a decade or two when it comes to elk. Before
following what Salazar Sez’s – because this is not a game and we are not children anymore - let’s take a
serious look at what “excess” wild horses and burros on public lands means to Secretary Salazar and BLM before
we blindly follow the newest Judas horse just released before the public.
Click on the link above to review the full collection of State by State analysis of wild horses and
burros populations compared to “everything else”, forage allocations of livestock, and available habitat on federally
managed lands.
(1) Taken from "Elk Management in 5 Western
States: (Montana, Wyoming, Idaho, Colorado, and Utah)".
.jpg) The Secretary of the Interior has suggested rounding up the wild horses and burros who run free in the West and confining
them to preserves in the East. Ken Salazar cited financial and environmental reasons for the idea, which would affect the 37,000 wild horses and burros living in Nevada,
California, Wyoming and other Western states and 32,000 horses and burros living in corrals and pastures in Kansas, Oklahoma
and South Dakota. He suggested capturing the animals and moving them to seven preserves. I can't help but think about
the First Peoples, living beings rounded up by the government and forced to live in designated areas. Two of the preserves
would be operated by the Bureau for Land Management, the entity that has rounded up wild horses each year and tried to sell
them. The remaining preserves would be constructed in the Midwest and the East.
"Unfortunately, arid western lands and watersheds cannot support a population this large without significant damage
to the environment," he said. But according to Greg Lawson, a National Park Service ranger, for each wild horse there are 160 cows on public land. Thirty-seven thousand horses
are a drop in the bucket compared to the number of cows raised and slaughtered on these lands each year. Imagine how much
water is takes to feed these cows, to dispose of their feces, to rinse the blood from the slaughterhouse floors. Although
The Associated Press story barely mentions ranching -- when describing Salazar's former livelihood -- that's what this is all about. Wild animals threaten
and reduce the space for cattle to graze, thereby affecting an animal ag's bottom line. If Salazar has his way, these
wild animals will be in a type of zoo.
Spokesman Tom Gorey said the land management agency would work with state and local officials to create the preserves
-- essentially large ranches -- and make them accessible to the public.
"We think there is real potential for ecotourism,"
he said. "Everybody loves horses." Everyone, that is, except those deciding their fate.
The Las Vegas I-Team and veteran reporter George Knapp's Special Investigative Report,
"Stampede To Oblivion", is now available on line with a link to the show in its entirety.
PLEASE URGE EVERYONE YOU KNOW TO WATCH THIS TIMELY AND IN DEPTH REPORT
ON THE CURRENT STATE OF THE WILD HORSE & BURRO PROGRAM!
by R.T. Fitch, author of “Straight from the Horse’s Heart“

When it comes to writing it takes a certain bit of motivation, emotion and passion for me to commit my feelings to written
word, hence, I am a total failure as a news writer. I wish that I had the ability to simply state the facts, present
the story and move on such as the talented equine writers Steven Long and John Holland manage to do; but I just don’t have it in me. The issue has to inspire, to push and drive me to make a point.
There is always a point so I wear a hat in hopes that it does not show. As my wife Terry will tell you, I
am a man of a few thousand words.
So as not to disappoint I sat down, last night, and began to compile a listing of all the anti-horse events that have transpired
over the past several months. I provided details, numbers, dates and names. I researched and documented until
I was blue in the face and then sat back and looked at what I had compiled. It was shocking, the list had grown and
swelled until more words were written than I could possibly put into a short “op-ed” and to add injury to insult,
I was depressed beyond words. In fact, I was beginning to feel an emotion that I have seen percolating amongst pro-horse
people and over the past several days has begun to bubble up to a rapid boil.
That’s when the red flags went up.
Today, logon to any equine advocate’s blog, check out a pro-horse website and you can quickly see that a tremendous
amount of justified frustration and pain is turning into something that, if not channeled correctly, could precipitate into
the demise of all that we have worked for in attempting to help the horses. That singular, destructive and dead-end
element is nothing more than all-American, apple pie, stick in your throat Anger.
There is nothing inherently wrong with feeling angry, Lord knows there is good reason, but a word of caution is justifiably
due. If we allow this emotion to mindlessly drive us down the same dark and slippery trail that the anti-horse people
are traveling, we have truly failed. The other side has a gigantic lead down the center of that abyss and the land of
negativity is somewhere we do not want to go; not now, not ever.
Take a moment and consider all of this from the horse’s perspective. That’s right, think like a horse
for a second and listen to what they have to say. Do you believe that the horses are angry? I think not.
They are frightened, frustrated and possibly lonely from having their families and homes destroyed but they don’t
know anger as we humans do. In fact, they run from it.
What’s the number #1 rule that you impose upon yourself when you feel angry at your horse? Isn’t it to
turn and walk out of the pasture as when you are angry you then repel the horse as you become the predator?
Perhaps there is a lesson learned there.
If we seek to effect change, then maybe we had better start thinking like horse trainers versus horse “breakers”.
Perhaps there is more to be gained from building relationships versus ramming our point of view down our opponent’s
throats.
Maybe if we attempt to display confidence, exhibit leadership, provide examples of success and clarity in the direction
that we would prefer to travel then like a horse, our former opponents might be more receptive to our perspective.
If, like a compassionate trainer, we can clearly show that our path is the way of least resistance and the destination
is the most comfortable place to be, then perchance we may cultivate more converts versus alienating the very horse that we
are trying to train.
When we first approach a horse, who we wish to build a relationship with, we already know that the horse sees the world
from a different perspective. We are fully aware that he/she does not trust us and that the horse has a mind of its
own and will want to do what he/she wants to do. The horse is going to push and shove to go where he/she wants to go;
until we can gently persuade he/she to do otherwise.
Is that not an exact definition of those whom we are most angry with right now?
Perhaps we should step away from our computer screens for a moment, take a deep breath, and put our horsemanship hats on.
If you have equine friends, now would be a good time to spend a few quiet moments with them and tune into their wavelengths.
Listen, for a change, instead of talking “to” them; recharge your emotional batteries.
If a friendly horse is not nearby; then close your eyes and imagine that high, lush, mountain meadow with vividly colored
wild flowers at your feet. You look about and see the small herd of wild horses calmly grazing around you while the
only sounds that you hear are their subtle chewing and the cry of a distant hawk. Tune in, breath deep and decompress.
Now; shake it off, put on your boots, slip into your chinks and head for the round pen.
We do a great job of convincing horses to behave as we desire so let’s give it a shot with humans and see where we
go. Instead of a carrot stick it might be a pen. Maybe a keyboard will take the place of a lunge line or a telephone
might supplant a savvy string but the tools are there, the knowledge is present and the desire is bursting at the seams.
Let’s stand united, suck it up and go train ourselves some horse advocates!
There is no where to go but up!
May the Force of the Horse be with you
Cloud’s Herd to be Rounded Up by Federally-Indicted Contractor
CHICAGO, (EWA) – A Temporary
Restraining Order (TRO) request by The Cloud Foundation and Front Range Equine Rescue was denied September 2, 2009 in Federal
District Court. The TRO was filed to stop the round up of the Pryor Mountain horses, an action unprecedented in size and scope.
The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) has contracted with the federally-indicted Dave Cattoor to round up America’s most
famous wild horse herd beginning September 3, 2009. Wild horse advocate and investigator, Julianne French, explains the situation
further in a youtube.com video posted today on The Cloud Foundation website.
In 1992, Cattoor was indicted by a federal grand jury for hunting wild horses,
aiding and abetting. Cattoor rounded up federally protected American mustangs, corralled them into pens and loaded them into
trucks bound for a Texas slaughterhouse. He pled guilty to those charges. “Since that time we suspect that he has received
at least $20,000,000,” says wild horse advocate, Julianne French. “And we know for sure, from the Federal Register
website, that Cattoor has earned over $12,000,000 in the past nine years alone.”
While Cattoor is currently under investigation by the Department of Interior
Inspector General for procurement fraud, BLM chooses to continue their relationship with the Cattoor Livestock Roundup Company.
“Generally, an indictment would eliminate a contractor from consideration,”
added French. “However, Mr. Cattoor has been rewarded and made a millionaire many times over by the taxpayer-funded
BLM—despite the public outrage.”
“If I ever had a felony charge, even if I had been exonerated, I’m
not supposed to get a federal contract” stated Howard Boggess, Crow Elder and Historian. “Why are they above the
law?”
A photographic report, The Use of Helicopters to Remove Wild Horses and Burros from Public Lands, displays
newborn foals run to exhaustion, found hog-tied on the range, horses and burros bleeding from their nostrils, broken legs
and injuries sustained during long gallops to capture pens.
Fully knowing the public’s concern about wild horse roundups BLM is
still debating whether independent humane observers will be granted access to round up operations in the Pryors. “Where
is the transparency and full-disclosure of this new administration?” asks Ginger Kathrens, Volunteer Executive Director
of the Cloud Foundation.
In the Pryor Wild Horse herd, young foals, only days old, will be rounded
up and potentially removed. BLM plans call for nearly all the 188 horses remaining in the Pryors to be rounded up in order
to apply infertility drugs. Seventy horses will be permanently removed and put up for adoption and sale on September 26, 2009.
According to noted geneticist Gus Cothran Ph.D. of Texas A&M University,
150 – 200 animals are required to maintain genetic viability. This removal would leave only 120 horses in the spectacular
Pryor Mountains. The Cloud Foundation is urging Americans to speak up now, or lose this unique herd forever.
www.thecloudfoundation.org
www.equinewelfarealliance.org
|